Skip to main content

Aire One Barrie

Gas or Electric Furnace: Which Suits a Craighurst Home?

Row of utility meters mounted along a wall, the cost side of a gas or electric furnace choice
10
November

Row of utility meters mounted along a wall, the cost side of a gas or electric furnace choice
Craighurst · Homeowner guide

100 percent efficient is not the same as cheap.

An electric furnace turns almost every unit of energy into heat. A gas furnace throws some away. Yet the gas unit usually costs less to run, because efficiency and price are different questions.

100%Electric resistance
90%+Condensing gas minimum
24/7Emergency service

5.0

Google rating from 131 reviews, as of November 10, 2026

Carrier Factory Authorized Dealer logo Technical Standards and Safety Authority logo HomeStars badge Aire One 30th anniversary badge Licensed technicians

Quick answer

Judge a gas or electric furnace on running cost, not on the efficiency rating. Electric resistance heat is “typically 100 per cent efficient.” Even so, Natural Resources Canada warns that electric heating now costs “quite high” amounts each year. Where a gas line reaches the property, gas normally wins on operating cost.

Key takeaways

  • Efficiency measures waste, while your bill follows the price of the fuel.
  • Electric resistance heating runs at about 100 percent efficiency.
  • Condensing gas furnaces must meet a minimum of 90 percent.
  • Electric units need no chimney, no venting and no combustion air.
  • Above all, a heat pump beats plain electric resistance on cost.

Why a gas or electric furnace cannot be judged on efficiency alone

First, separate two ideas that sound identical. Efficiency describes how much of the energy you buy becomes heat.

By contrast, cost describes what that energy costs in the first place. These two move independently.

Electric resistance scores almost perfectly. Natural Resources Canada explains that such equipment is “typically 100 per cent efficient” because nothing escapes up a chimney.

Meanwhile gas scores lower on paper. Even so, the federal guide notes that condensing furnaces must meet a minimum of “90 percent” efficiency under the Regulations.

Therefore the gas unit wastes more energy and still often costs less to run. The price per unit decides the outcome, not the rating on the label.

Close-up of a cast iron radiator in a home
Whatever makes the heat, the house only feels what reaches the room.

How each one actually works

Secondly, the hardware. An electric furnace is compact and mechanically simple.

Natural Resources Canada describes a single cabinet holding “the heating elements, circulation fan, air filter, and control devices.”

Both types then move heat the same way. Each one “delivers heated air blown by a fan through a network of ducts.”

By contrast, the gas unit burns fuel and must deal with the results. Modern condensing models handle that neatly.

In fact, it needs no chimney. The flue gas runs cool enough to leave “through an approved plastic pipe.”

Moreover those units “can generally be vented out a side wall and do not use air from the home for combustion.”

They also produce water. The guide routes that condensate “to a floor drain or condensate pump.”

Question Electric furnace Gas furnace
Rated efficiency About 100 percent 90 percent minimum, condensing
Venting None required Side wall plastic pipe
Combustion air Not applicable Drawn from outdoors
Condensate drain Not applicable Floor drain or pump
Gas line needed No Yes
Typical running cost Higher in Ontario Lower where gas is available

What a gas or electric furnace really costs to run

Thirdly, the number that matters over a decade. Natural Resources Canada is candid about electric heating in today’s market.

It states that “the annual cost to heat such a home has become quite high.”

Homeowners have noticed. The guide reports that “an increasing number” of them are leaving electric baseboard heating for other energy sources.

Meanwhile rates vary by household and by time of use. Consequently the only honest comparison uses your own bills and local prices.

Ask for that calculation in writing before you commit. A quote without it compares equipment, not outcomes.

When the electric furnace still wins

However, a gas or electric furnace choice is not always open to you. Availability settles it first.

Simply put, no gas line means no gas furnace. Properties beyond the distribution network choose among electricity, propane and oil instead.

Besides, installation runs simpler. A gas or electric furnace differ most here, since the electric unit needs no flue, no combustion air intake and no condensate drain.

In addition, there are no combustion by-products indoors. That removes one category of safety concern entirely.

Still, Natural Resources Canada adds a fair caveat. Generating electricity “impacts the environment as well, even though it is clean at the point of use.”

Bundle of black and copper pipes bending along a wall
Distribution matters as much as the appliance. Seal it while it is open.

The option that beats both on electricity

Next, the alternative worth pricing before you decide. A heat pump moves heat rather than creating it.

Natural Resources Canada explains the advantage plainly. Transferring heat “takes less energy” than generating it, so “heat pumps can be very energy efficient.”

Consequently a heat pump undercuts plain electric resistance on cost. Indeed, for an all-electric home that comparison matters more than the gas or electric furnace brand.

Air-source models do fade in deep cold, though. Both “efficiency and capacity decrease” as outside temperatures drop.

Ground-source systems avoid that fade entirely. Our guide to the Ontario heat pump rebate covers the support available.

What this means around Craighurst

Craighurst sits at the Highway 93 and Horseshoe Valley Road corner in Oro-Medonte, surrounded by rural lots.

Moreover, servicing varies sharply across short distances. One road may have gas while the next concession does not.

Therefore the gas or electric furnace question is often settled by the utility map rather than by preference. Confirm availability at your exact address first.

Our guide to heating options walks through checking that. Where ducts already exist, you “can usually use the existing ductwork with very few modifications.”

Finally, seal those ducts while they are open. The federal guide recommends sealing joints “with a special water-based duct mastic” to stop warm air leaking away.

Talk to Aire One Barrie

Furthermore, we price every gas or electric furnace option against your own bills, in writing. We serve Oro-Medonte and the rest of Simcoe County from our Barrie shop.

  • 24/7 emergency service, including weekends and holidays
  • We calculate heat loss before quoting any furnace
  • Written quotes you can compare line by line
  • Bonded, factory trained and licensed technicians
Aire One Heating & Cooling Barrie · 176 Burton Ave, Barrie, ON · 705-733-1003

Frequently asked questions

Is an electric furnace cheaper to run than a gas furnace?

Usually not, wherever gas reaches the property. Natural Resources Canada notes that the annual cost of heating a home electrically has become quite high. It also reports homeowners moving away from electric baseboard heating.

Why is an electric furnace 100 percent efficient but still expensive?

Efficiency measures how much of the energy you buy becomes heat, not what that energy costs. Electric resistance heating wastes almost nothing. However, electricity usually costs more per unit of heat than natural gas does.

Does a gas furnace need a chimney?

Not a condensing one. Natural Resources Canada explains that the flue gas runs cool enough for approved plastic pipe. High-efficiency units also vent out a side wall and draw combustion air from outdoors.

Can I keep my existing ducts if I switch?

Usually yes. The federal guide says you can normally keep the existing ductwork with very few modifications. It also recommends sealing the joints with a water-based duct mastic during the changeover.

Should I consider a heat pump instead?

If your home runs all electric, yes. Natural Resources Canada points out that transferring heat takes less energy than generating it. Heat pumps therefore run very efficiently, although air-source capacity falls in deep cold.

Henry Tabarsi, General Manager

Aire One has served Ontario since 1990, with Carrier Factory Authorized Dealer status and licensed technicians across Simcoe County.

705-733-1003 · 176 Burton Ave, Barrie, ON

Sources

  1. Natural Resources Canada, Heating with Electricity — the 100 percent efficiency of electric resistance heating, the compact cabinet layout, forced-air definition, high annual electric heating costs, homeowners switching fuels, reusing existing ductwork, duct mastic, and heat pump efficiency in cold weather.
  2. Natural Resources Canada, Heating with Gas — the 90 percent minimum efficiency for condensing furnaces, plastic pipe and side wall venting, outdoor combustion air, condensate drainage, and the environmental note on generating electricity.